Chinese spy balloon shot down off the coast of the Carolinas

A Chinese spy balloon was spotted by civilians over Montana. It floated over the United States until it was shot down by a F-22 fighter jet on Feb. 4. Photo courtesy of Chase Doak via Wikimedia Commons.

Elizabeth Murray ’26

Staff Writer

On Wednesday, Feb. 1, 2023, a Chinese surveillance balloon was spotted by civilians flying over Montana, The Washington Post reported. In the following days, the balloon made its way across the continental United States. It was shot down off the coast of South Carolina on February 4 by an F-22 fighter jet. According to NPR, reactions varied from the serious — such as Secretary of State Anthony Blinken canceling his diplomatic trip to Beijing — to the trivial, including a Saturday Night Live cold open featuring the balloon played by Bowen Yang. 

CNN reported on new details that have emerged regarding the capabilities of the balloon since it was shot down. This balloon was part of a larger fleet, and reports have emerged of additional balloons floating over Latin America and the U.S., the article explained. According to Time magazine, the balloon was equipped with “multiple antennas … likely capable of collecting and geolocating communications,” a U.S. official stated. The “undercarriage” of the balloon — where the surveillance equipment is believed to be housed — was spotted among the debris, ABC News said. 

Professor Calvin Chen, professor of politics at Mount Holyoke College explained that the use of the balloon comes off as unusual for a country that is widely viewed as being at the forefront of technology. “The fact that they were using balloons perplexed me because they have way more satellites, good satellites. They have an orbit that can be used for surveillance and other purposes. To be caught like this and have it shot down, and have all this kind of bad PR, is a little bit of a head-scratcher to me,” he said.

The political reaction in the U.S. has put a strain on what was already a frosty relationship between the U.S. and China. “Relations between the U.S. and China have been quite tense for some time and this will only make things worse,” Professor Andrew Reiter, associate professor of politics and international relations at Mount Holyoke College, said. 

According to CNN, a spokesman for the Chinese Ministry of Defense responded to the shooting of the balloon by saying, “The U.S. used force to attack our civilian unmanned airship, which is an obvious overreaction. We express solemn protest against this move by the U.S.’ side.” This international incident caused a domestic stir in Congress as well, with senators and representatives of both parties criticizing the Biden Administration’s hesitation to shoot down the balloon, a Politico article said. According to a Reuters article on the issue, Biden addressed this in his State of the Union speech: “I am committed to work with China where we can advance American interests and benefit the world,” he said. “But make no mistake about it: as we made clear last week, if China threatens our sovereignty, we will act to protect our country. And we did.”  

Looking ahead, relations between the U.S. and China are likely to remain tense. The U.S. and other countries are now on high alert for unfamiliar objects in their airspace.According to the Associated Press, in the span of eight days, four similar objects have been shot down by U.S. fighter jets.  According to NBC News, China has also accused the U.S. of flying spy balloons over their airspace, meaning that the issue will likely be a point of diplomatic contention between the two countries.

US ends 20 year old war, leaving Afghani civilians in the lurch

By Madhavi Rao ’24

Staff Writer

After a 20-year insurgency against the U.S. government, the Taliban, an Islamic militant organization, has taken control of Afghanistan. The extremist takeover was hastened by the U.S.’s withdrawal of troops from Afghanistan in July and August 2021. The militant group's seizure of power has caused human rights concerns for citizens of Afghanistan.

On April 14, President Joe Biden announced that U.S. troops would withdraw from Afghanistan, ending an ongoing war that spanned two decades. Biden stated that “[The U.S.] no longer had a clear purpose in an open-ended mission in Afghanistan,” Al-Jazeera reported. This decision was fully implemented on the Aug. 31 deadline, when the last U.S. troops left the country. The withdrawal of the U.S. military led to the rapid conquest of the country by the Taliban, resulting in the extremist organization’s capture of the capital, Kabul, on Aug. 15. 

During the reign of the Soviet Union, the USSR extended forces to Afghanistan as a way of supporting the communist government that existed there. In 1989, the Soviets were driven out by Islamic fighters. The subsequent power vacuum led to the creation of the Taliban, an Islamic extremist group consisting mostly of students, in 1994. When it first emerged, the group was described as consisting of “Islamic purists and Afghan patriots” by The New York Times. The movement was initially welcomed as a form of relief against the Afghan warlords that played a part in driving out the Soviet soldiers. However, in 1996, the Taliban declared Afghanistan an “Islamic Emirate,” ruling with a conservative view of the religion which was intolerant of other religions and oppressive of women’s freedoms. By 1998, the militant group had taken control of most of the country. 

Following the 2001 attack by the terrorist group al-Qaeda on the Twin Towers in New York City, Osama bin Laden, the head of al-Qaeda, was harbored by the Taliban in Afghanistan. The U.S. military launched airstrikes alongside Afghan Northern Alliance ground forces and deposed the Taliban rulers when they refused to hand over bin Laden. According to BBC News, the U.S. vowed to “support democracy and eliminate the terrorist threat” in Afghanistan. The Taliban returned, and the situation escalated into the longest war that the U.S. has fought. With the withdrawal of the last U.S. troops on Aug. 31, the future of Afghanistan under Taliban rule is uncertain. 

“For at least the past ten years, the Taliban controlled at least half of Afghan territory,”  chair of International Relations on the Alumnae Foundation and Professor of Politics Sohail Hashmi said. “The people in rural Afghanistan — the majority of the population — have been under Taliban rule. The choice facing President Biden was to prolong this stalemate for yet another presidential administration, escalate American troop presence to respond to escalating Taliban attacks, or pull out,” Hashmi continued. “In my opinion, President Obama made a crucial mistake when he decided to continue the American presence in Afghanistan after Osama bin Laden was killed in 2011. Remember, the U.S. attacked Afghanistan in 2001 to eliminate the threat from al-Qaeda coming from that country. Ten years later, bin Laden was killed not in Afghanistan, but deep in Pakistan.”

“Over the 20-year arc of the war, it has been a story of U.S. overreach and, at times, a self-deluding refusal to face facts,” American journalist David Ignatius wrote in an opinion piece for The Washington Post. 

“The problem with the evacuation, in part, was that military and civilian efforts were operating on different clocks,” Ignatius said. “The military raced out by July 1, embracing the generals’ credo, ‘speed is safety,’ and leaving behind only a token force of 650.” He continued, “The civilian withdrawal proceeded at a slower pace, moving more like ‘pond water’ than a rushing torrent, in the words of one four-star general. That was partly because Biden had promised President Ashraf Ghani to avoid a rush for the exits that might trigger a panic. It turned out that it was Ghani himself who panicked and fled for his life, handing Kabul to the Taliban.”

Omid, a 26-year-old Afghani medical student, told Al-Jazeera, “They gave us pens and taught us about freedom, and then just as quickly, they took it all away,” referencing the end of U.S. presence in the country. In an interview with the news outlet, he went on to explain that the main concern for many Afghani civilians at the moment is staying out of poverty, as well as finding a means of leaving the country. 

Abhilash Medhi, assistant professor of history at Mount Holyoke College, commented on the conditions of people in the country: “In terms of inflation, food security, poverty, etc. the country might face similar problems as it did under Taliban rule in the 1990s. People are already lining up to sell household items for money. One statistic states that one third of the country now has food insecurity.”

One reason for the economic instability is the withdrawal of U.S. aid to the country. Foreign aid accounts for nearly half the legal economy of Afghanistan, according to a report by The New York Times, meaning that stopping this inflow of cash could lead to a serious financial crisis in the nation. The exit of U.S. troops also removed a major source of tax revenue from the country. 

The Taliban’s conservative views are also a source of concern when considering the country’s future. In a report on the conditions of human rights in Afghanistan, Amnesty International stated, “Women and girls continued to face gender-based discrimination and violence throughout Afghanistan, especially in areas under Taliban control, where their rights were violated with impunity and violent ‘punishments’ were meted out for perceived transgressions of the armed group’s interpretation of Islamic law.” 

Medhi further clarified, “A large portion of the country was already under Taliban rule. In the south and the east, in regions such as Helmand, Wardak and Paktia, there were entire districts which were already controlled by the Taliban.” Medhi continued, “The Taliban’s strict doctrine is not dissimilar to how some ethnic groups, such as the Pashtuns, were already living. However, for groups such as the Hazaras, the Uzbeks and the Tajiks, these developments can be very troubling. The Taliban takeover means very different things for people based on their ethnicity and gender.” 

Massoud, a shopkeeper in the capital city of Kabul, told Al-Jazeera, “The former governments were full of corrupt thieves, but now, we have no freedoms.”